Kitchen
Vic Firth Pepper Mill
by Vic Firth
54
2 endorsements on r/BuyItForLife first recommended in Jun 2025
A discontinued pepper mill with metal internal parts and grinder, still findable secondhand on eBay; a commenter reports the identical grinder is still sold new by Fletchers Mill.
Added Jul 5, 2026, Updated Jul 7, 2026
Why it's buy-it-for-life
A commenter with two units says they grind very smoothly and the second, bought secondhand years after discontinuation, was still in excellent shape. A separate owner of two Vic Firth mills calls them an all-time favorite and says Fletchers Mill still sells the identical grinder today.
What redditors say
Recommended on reddit as recently as June 2025
Tags
pepper-mill discontinued all-metal secondhand
Im a big fan of Vic Firth grinders. Very smooth... Metal parts/grinder inside.
Fletcher Mills. I have two of the Vic Firth version they still sell the identical grinder.
No one has mentioned Vic Firth yet